Category Archives: politics
Powerless!
India broke a world record. And the world paid attention (rightly so). The news grabbed headlines internationally. It did not have anything to do with the Olympics. It did not even have to do with cricket. You know what that means? Even the non-Commonwealth countries got into the act and came away spellbound and amazed.
By the time you read this, I would hope that this is old news. I really hope!
India now holds the dubious record of having the largest power cut ever in the history of the world.
The power went out for two days in a row when the electrical grid went down. And on that second day which was the worst ever, more than 600 million people along great swathes of the country – the Northern and Eastern states of India were severely impacted (this is more than the entire population of EU!).
:
Both Indian outages were the world’s largest by far. The next closest was a 2005 blackout that affected 100 million people in Indonesia. What a reason for ‘India Shining’ to make headlines around the world! 😦
Like I said, hopefully this is old news by the time this post goes up and that there have been no other such crippling occurrences in India since then.
There’s lots you can read about the topic so I won’t repeat it here. I thought I would focus, instead, on some of the reactions of people in and out of India.
This was a seriously massive problem but that doesn’t mean you can’t have a chuckle or two at its expense, or vent your frustration. As people in India do.
Media here (as well as citizens) had a field day. The best headline, by far, that I came upon was this from The Economic Times; it took up a huge chunk of the cover page real estate.
SuperPOWER India, RIP
BBC showcased all the Indian headlines here. Have a look.
From various, random sources, I picked out some quotes and comments from Indian citizens, and a few from non-Indians too – some for their insight or anger, others for their entertainment value. But even those with humor and wit have an undercurrent of sadness and dismay about them.
“This news bring shame to India in world’s eyes … I don’t think any outside investor in a right mind can invest in India. If given the chance, even Indians would invest outside than here.”
“Delhi is powerless is a known fact. For they want only political power in UP and Centre. They are not worried about the people suffering without power for their daily routine. India will surely become superpower in 3025.”
“This awful power grid failure should act as the wake up call for the slumbering and dithering govt to reform the power sector on an urgent basis.”
“People in the know have been saying that India’s development is a sham, and is not real. The infrastructure quality is pathetic, and that the institutions are not reliable, since the country reeks of corruption in every aspect. But, the media hype was such that any attempt to suggest that development funds were being pilfered thru poor quality of delivery fell on deaf ears. Now the world can see for itself, the colossal collapse of electricity infrastructure affecting 600 million people. What better proof was required that all state governments are run in the most incompetent manner possible. Nothing about India inspires confidence – atleast not with current and future crop of political leadership.”
“While the world was waiting for India’s ‘Golden Moment’ to finally arrive, the Mother of all Blackouts happened. ‘India Shining’ now sounds like the ultimate misnomer. India needs to give up its dreams of becoming a ‘superpower’ when it cannot even provide clean drinking water, clean toilets, clean food, and now electricity to most of it’s population. Most Indians still live in poverty worse than sub-Saharan Africa.”
“Too much outsourcing is straining the grid.”
“I can not reach my customer service rep! What is de problem?”
Click on picture for “Power Grid Failures a Wake-up Call for Aspiring India” from The Hindustan Times
“Our worthy power minister elevated as home minister for this feat.” [Note: The day after the massive blackout, in an unrelated power shift at the Capital, the then power minister was given the Home ministry – a much larger charter – and therefore a promotion!]
“Is it any surprise that we have reached this pass? Well this is the start and we shall see many more similar events. There used to be a method in the madness, but now the method has been lost and only madness prevails. When we see the country is being looted by all and sundry and we have no respect to a fellow human being where else do you believe this country will go. There will come a time when the people of this country will rise as they have already started doing, woe betide the politicians. I sincerely hope and believe that if this country is to progress at all we need decision makers in the Government whose first priority should be the welfare of the citizens and not how to enrich themselves and so long as we have the current crop of criminals ruling this country there is no hope at all.”
“India is the first country to invent a time-machine. It was tested successfully for 2 days. The North Indians were the privileged ones to travel twice to “Dark Ages” and back.”
“Wow, look at all the BRILLIANT ENGINEERS in India. They can’t even keep the power on.”
And the reply to this: “Engineers did their job of tripping the line when the load was high, it’s time the politicians stopped eating into the money allocated for system expansion. Otherwise, the results are evident.”
“I appeal all fellow Indians to go out in large numbers and vote AGAINST Congresss/UPA in the next general elections. Losing elections is the greatest punishment for any party”
“Lest we forget. Gujarat stood alone – with absolutely no cuts. Meanwhile it continues to export electricity to the rest of India.”
“The Gujarat example really does help to show that it is possible for all of India to have continuous power and that it’s not just a fanciful dream”
“Stop electing the wrong people.”
“China should build India’s infrastructure. A looming property bubble means a construction bust; all this capacity and nothing to do with it. India needs the infrastructure, China has the know-how.”
“Well, as far as I can tell, there actually was minimal impact on the daily lives of middle class people in Delhi. I guess the reason is that all of them have pretty robust power backup systems. Much more robust than the state owned companies. Therein lies another of “India’s big success stories” as the economist noted.”
“Government in India has been useless for the last 65 years and that should be considered as a given. In the early 90s, when Indian girls were winning beauty contests worldwide, there was this saying that India was doing well in Fashion and IT because those were not government focus areas.“
“The world’s largest democracy is now also the world’s largest ‘blackout superpower’. At one go, 1,000,000 (one billion) Indians were powerless (and speechless?). Consider that 350 million Indians have no electricity to lose and another 650 million Indians suddenly lose their electricity. A state that fails it’s people this badly is a failed state.”
“India gets a pass for its drawbacks because it is a democracy. By allowing bids from states to undermine the national electrical grid, the national government has essentially created a ready excuse for failure. Why do states even get what is in a effect a vote on a national energy policy? Let’s face it: Democracy is a difficult process and not all countries are fully capable of it. It is an absurd act of faith to believe that the costs of democratic governance are worth every possible disadvantage, and yet this has been a major tenet of Western ideology for a century or more.
Countries whose economic conditions are far more pressing than any political deficit could benefit from a realistic appraisal of available solutions rather than blindly following a path that leads to continued underdevelopment and harm. The fact that India takes pride in its democracy shouldn’t fool anyone into belief that its democratic process places it above others simply because votes are cast. Stories like these indicate the opposite: That India’s democracy is a great hindrance to its prosperity and that democracy itself may be a severe impediment to growth.“
“The political leaders always have their kind of answers to console the mass: ‘such calamities happen in developed countries as well.‘ The emerging-superpower-status is still intact,and everybody can go back to sleep.“
There are usually as many opinions as people. In India that translates to over a billion. But, in this case, universally the largest blame for this was cast on a highly corrupt government – and there was no boundary to this – it was at national, state and local levels.
Hard to question reality!
:
:
:
Photo Credits:
India Map: By Whoever uploaded India_states_and_union_territories_map.svg to English Wikipedia (India_states_and_union_territories_map.svg) [CC-BY-SA-1.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/1.0)%5D, via Wikimedia Commons
Oh “India Shining”, Wherefore Art Thou?
A Catchy Sound Bite
India Shining was a slogan popularized by one of the leading political parties (BJP) during the elections of 2004. It was supposed to reflect the economic optimism of an emerging giant.
Prior to that, the Indian government had used it to market the country internationally. Since that time, it’s no lie to say that there was remarkable success in transforming the image of this country in the eyes of so many – within the nation, as well as far and wide, outside these borders.
In fact, many Indians seem to still believe that India Shining is the reality – if not now, then soon. To me, it feels like they’re fooling themselves – either immersed in naiveté or patriotic self-deception.
But Reality Bites
Here’s some of what is happening in this country that is leading me to this conclusion:
Economic Growth: Below expectations.
Inflation: High and rising.
Rupee: Down, way down…the lowest ever against the dollar last week.
Per Capita Debt: Rising steeply.
Industrial Output: Declining.
Trade Deficit: Growing.
Government: Paralyzed – by coalitions and many pockets of self-interest. Except perhaps for removing cartoons from text books. Big 😦 .
Alternative political party strength: Not very hopeful.
Corruption: Healthy. No, make that thriving.
Innovation: Huh?
Social Indicators: Declining. (Bangla Desh has overtaken India in nearly all of them).
India versus China: Sheesh…here’s one write-up on the topic – The elephant can not fly like the dragon unless winged.
Foreign Investment: Fleeing.
BRICS: What’s on its way – The “I “for India to be replaced by Indonesia.
Okay, so go ahead and ask me…am I not being a tad harsh here? Isn’t the entire world experiencing a similar plight, especially economically? Aah, but while the entire world is experiencing this plight, the India growth story was supposedly intact and one of few exceptions. No more!
Here’s something scary I just read. The Financial Times asked a Western investor – What ails India? The reply: Everything. And then he went on further to say: “On every indicator we look at, there is a red flag. This country is close to becoming the Greece of Asia.”
Is that scary or what?!
Worried Yet?
People here need to get their heads out of the sand, stop being content with things as they are, stop believing all the hype about India Rising and India Shining, stop focusing all their attention on cricket and Bollywood, and wonder what is really happening to this country and what they can do about it!
Thomas Jefferson said about America – “I predict future happiness for Americans, if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them.” For all its faults, that country’s various governments over its short history have done more to accomplish this (prosperity and the pursuit of happiness) than virtually any other. And the beauty of that democracy is that it allows this to happen.
A government that genuinely takes care of its people rather than of its politicians can affect the same positive outcome in India. This is a democracy too. Isn’t it?
Mammoth Potential
You say then, is there no hope for India?
Hah! But then you are asking a Pollyanna this question. Of course, there is hope!
What is left that we can hope for are the two P’s.
PEOPLE – all that human capital (and so much of it so young!) – surely among them there are some true leaders for the nation.
POTENTIAL – all that budding energy and those resources, waiting to be harnessed.
Now, India just needs something or many someones who care enough to put these together and make them work FOR this country.
As someone once said: “The potential of the average person [nation?] is like a huge ocean unsailed, a new continent unexplored, a world of possibilities waiting to be released and channeled toward some great good.”
But as someone else once said – “Potential has a shelf life”.
Sometimes, people (and governments?) mobilize towards solutions when a crisis looms. That time is now. Time for the real “India Shining” – the one that is waiting to be discovered behind an empty slogan.
Yes, I simply talk and write. And wish. But what I would do, if it did happen in my lifetime!
If only.
:
:
The Yin and Yang of Life Anywhere 